
I grew up hunting for boys like me in books. Sometimes I found a sidekick. Sometimes a joke. Lately, I’ve found leads. Real leads. It still hits me. I read most of these on the bus, on my porch, and once in the tub with cold coffee. Not great for the coffee. Great for my heart.
Here’s the thing: I love craft talk—character voice, pacing, POV—but I also care how a book feels in my gut. Did it make me grin? Did it make me call my best friend? That matters too.
Below are real books with gay leads that I read. Some I adored. Some I argued with. All gave me something.
If you’re hungry for an even deeper bench of titles, swing by Gay Book Reviews for a treasure trove of fresh takes and recommendations. You’ll also find their in-depth roundup on this very theme—“Books With a Gay Protagonist: What I Read, What Stuck, What Stung”—which pairs perfectly with the list below. For still more curated picks, release calendars, and spoiler-free insights, check out MM Bookworm Reviews and Releases, a go-to hub for the latest in queer fiction.
Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda — Becky Albertalli
I read this on a rainy Saturday with a blanket and a snack. Simon is a sweet, messy teen who emails a secret crush named Blue. The tone is bright. The voice feels like an actual junior year brain—funny, kind, and a little scared.
- What I loved: The Ferris wheel scene got me good. The email banter felt warm. It’s a solid coming-out arc that doesn’t punish him for being happy.
- What bugged me: The ending ties up neat, like TV. Some drama feels safe. But you know what? Sometimes safe is needed. That’s not nothing.
Red, White & Royal Blue — Casey McQuiston
I saved this for a long flight. Bad idea. I laughed so much my seatmate kept peeking. It’s about the First Son and a British prince. Politics plus romance plus texts with too many heart emojis.
- What I loved: Big rom-com energy. Henry stole my heart—dry and tender at once. The emails had rhythm and heat.
- What bugged me: It runs long. A few scenes play like a movie montage. Still, I finished and felt lighter. Not mad about that.
Less — Andrew Sean Greer
I read Less during a weird winter week when I needed a win. Arthur Less is a mid-list gay writer who runs away from his life by saying yes to every event invite. He’s awkward; he’s kind; he trips over love.
- What I loved: The humor. It’s sly, not loud. The travel bits felt real—bland conference food, jet lag thoughts at 3 a.m. The last pages land soft but strong.
- What bugged me: A few chapters feel precious. Like the style is doing a bit. I still hugged the book when I finished. Yes, I’m that person.
The House in the Cerulean Sea — TJ Klune
I read this on my porch in June. Warm air. Bird noise. Linus, a rule-following case worker, visits a home for magic kids. He meets Arthur, who runs the place. The vibe is cozy. Think tea, cardigans, and found family.
- What I loved: It’s gentle. The romance is soft and patient. The kids sparkle without being props.
- What bugged me: It can be very sweet. Like marshmallow. Some readers have said parts echo real pain about how kids get treated, and that can feel heavy. For me, the heart still worked, but I sat with that.
Giovanni’s Room — James Baldwin
I read this one slow. One chapter a night. It’s set in Paris and it aches. David, the narrator, falls for Giovanni. The prose is clean and sharp. It cuts and glows.
- What I loved: The sentences. They hum. Baldwin shows shame and longing with no waste. The bar scenes feel like they’re still there, smoke and all.
- What bugged me: It’s bleak. David’s self-hate is hard to carry. I needed to take breaks. Worth it, but not a subway read if your heart is tender.
The Song of Achilles — Madeline Miller
I took this on a beach trip and, well, I cried behind my sunglasses. Patroclus tells the story of Achilles with love and care. War, pride, fate—big themes, simple pulse.
- What I loved: The romance feels patient and real. The quiet moments hit harder than the battles.
- What bugged me: The middle lingers. A few war parts got samey. But the last third? My chest hurt, in a good way.
Boyfriend Material — Alexis Hall
I wanted something fun, so I grabbed this for a long bus ride. Fake dating. Real feelings. London jokes. Luc is a chaos magnet; Oliver is very neat. Classic odd couple.
- What I loved: Banter for days. I snorted on page 40 and scared a toddler. The emotional beats feel earned.
- What bugged me: Some humor leans British TV. If that’s not your lane, a few lines may miss. Also, it’s a tad long for a rom-com. Still, I was in.
The Guncle — Steven Rowley
I read this after a rough week, and it felt like a warm towel. Patrick, a former TV star, cares for his young niece and nephew after a loss. He’s gay and glamorous, but he’s also lonely.
- What I loved: Big heart. Silly and sad in the same breath. The kids sound like kids, not tiny adults.
- What bugged me: The quips can be too cute. Now and then I wanted less sparkle, more quiet. The quiet parts are the best parts.
Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe — Benjamin Alire Sáenz
I took this one to the park and forgot about my phone. Ari and Dante are two Mexican American boys in the ‘80s. They swim, they talk, they learn who they are. It’s slow, like summer.
- What I loved: Small scenes with big weight. A truck ride. A backyard. A father who tries. The voice is still water.
- What bugged me: Not much “plot” for a while. If you want big twists, this isn’t it. I liked the quiet. It moved me.
Simon Says Quick Craft Notes
I can’t help it. I like the nerd stuff.
- Voice: “Simon” and “Ari” nail teen voice; “Less” nails middle-aged panic with grace.
- Pacing: “Red, White & Royal Blue” and “Boyfriend Material” push quick. “Giovanni’s Room” and “Achilles” take their time and crush your heart slowly.
- POV: First person works best when the inner world is rich. That’s why “Giovanni’s Room” haunts.
A Few Real Moments That Stayed With Me
- Simon on the Ferris wheel, hoping he guessed right. My stomach flipped too.
- Arthur Less walking a city he doesn’t quite know, trying not to look lost. Been there.
- Henry’s email that felt like a confession and a dare. I reread it three times.
- Ari sitting with a truth he almost can’t touch. Soft and sharp at once.
Heads-Up, Because Care Matters
- Topics: Some books carry grief, shame, and homophobia. “Giovanni’s Room” is heavy. “The Guncle” deals with loss. You’ll want tea and maybe a friend to text.
- Age range: “Simon” and “Ari & Dante” fit teens. The rest lean adult. “Red, White & Royal Blue” has heat. So does “Boyfriend Material.”
- Language: A few have strong language and sex talk. Nothing wild, but know your comfort.
- Curiosity about queer dating IRL: If a character's flirtatious dialogue leaves you curious about how casual connections happen off the page, peek at this detailed Snapfuck review that breaks down features, cost, and safety so you can decide if the app fits your vibe.
- Planning a road-trip through Idaho and craving a queer-friendly place to unwind? For some real-world R&R options, the local rundown at Rubmaps Twin Falls delivers crowd-sourced reviews, location details, and safety notes so you can book a massage stop that feels welcoming and low-stress.
Where to Start? Mood Picks
- Want a warm hug: The House in the Cerulean Sea or The Guncle
- Want big romance: Red, White & Royal Blue or Boyfriend Material
- Want a classic punch: Giovanni’s Room
- Want quiet beauty: Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe
- Want wit with heart: Less
- Want myth and feelings: The Song of Achilles
- Want teen joy with emails: Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda
Small, Honest Wrap-Up
I didn’t always see guys like me in stories. Now I do, and it still feels new. These books aren’t perfect. Some are too long. Some are too tidy. Some are heavy and left me wrung out.
But

